For obvious reasons, I get asked this question a lot as of late. My answer depends on who is asking it and where we are when I am being asked. The most obvious answer at the moment is ‘America’. If people push for specifics I say, ‘Most recently, Boston’. (Interestingly, I have lived in Boston more years (almost 20) than any other place in my life, but I have never referred to myself as a Bostonian.) I have been thinking about this a lot…how will I be answering that question a year from now?
At the moment, I feel like I am floating; not exactly a man without a country in the Philip Nolan sense, but unsure where I am from at this particular point in time. I don’t feel fully a part of any place. Right now I am living and working in England; I still have belongings and a place in Boston; in addition there are some MORE of my things at my parents’ in New Jersey. While my address remains in Boston, my mail is being forwarded to NJ. As George Carlin would say, 'I've got s*!t all over the place!' Well, what happens when I no longer have a place in Boston? I have a Massachusetts driver’s license; is that proof of where I am from? What about when I am no longer connected there? In addition I have both Irish and American passports. I certainly am not ‘from’ Ireland in the way I am ‘from’ America, but I am recognized as a citizen of both nations. (Odd, I am current a citizen of two countries but reside in neither….damn this is getting complicated.)
I only shipped over minimal possessions as I am renting a furnished flat. Many of my friends know that I am not one who likes to own ‘big’ things (that is, stuff bigger than I am). I have only had a car for 2 weeks of my life (when I was 20). I have never owned real estate of any kind (and have no desire to). Currently, the biggest things I own are a few pieces of furniture; bed, dresser, desk, chairs, a TV. They are in Boston, and I am trying to figure out what to do with them (and the thousand smaller things) when I visit in August. When I do dispose of them (in some way; selling, shipping, storing or throwing out) and I leave my place in Boston, does that mean I am REALLY from here (from that point on)? If so, where am I FROM now? Seems Einstein was right, we can not separate time and space as easily as we pretend we can.
The possessions I did bring or ship with me (besides clothes) are objects that are familiar and help to make a space feel like mine; a few small paintings I bought in Prague, some knick knacks (a few given by friends, students and others over the years) selected photos and that is about it. I guess for me it is an attempt to make a space ‘mine’ in some ways (and it beats how dogs mark their territory!) Still, I don’t feel ‘here’ yet, but I certainly am not ‘there’.
I guess this all this rambling is trying to sort out exactly what concepts like ‘place’ and ‘home’ and ‘I am from X’ really mean for me. Any thoughts/comments/observations are welcome.
QWERTY forever: path dependency
5 hours ago